“God Became Man that Man Might Become God”

Perfect Union -- Father Son Spirit Bride

This provocative statement, “God became man that man might become God,” is from the church father Athanasius (ca 298–373), and was in his massively influential On the Incarnation.  It is one of his best-known quotes.

Let me explain what I’m going to do here. First, I briefly discuss some “recent” highlights of the popular deification discussion.  Second, I present a skeletal description of the Johannine and Pauline foundations for the doctrine, and briefly share how I understand them. Third, I discuss what it has done for me, and to me, personally–the effect it has had on my life. Finally, I share some concluding thoughts.

Deification in Recent History

I used to be under the mistaken impression that the doctrine of theosis, or deification, was basically an Eastern Orthodox doctrine.  A few years ago, however, I was surprised to find the Athanasius quote highlighted prominently in the first few pages of the Roman Catholic catechism.  “God became man so that man might become God.” This statement of Athanasius is not some bizarre, minority opinion held by heretics, non-Christians, and cults. Many church fathers after Athanasius quoted and paraphrased him, and it is still a Catholic and Orthodox teaching to this day.

The closest Protestants come is Wesley’s teaching on Christian Perfection, although variations were taught by a few lesser-known teachers like Witness Lee and John Robert Stevens. In 1975 the Christian Literature Crusade published an excellent book, Destined for the Throne, by Paul Billheimer. Billheimer’s book, however, was too close to “heresy” for the taste of American evangelicals, and Billy Graham assisted in the publication of a watered-down version in 2005.  Deification, which is based squarely on scripture, is considered heresy by various cult watch and Christian apologists. I believe that the doctrine’s Mormon expression is among the top reasons for the virtual refusal of Protestant leaders to teach deification, despite its strong Biblical foundation. One popular denunciation of deification was Neil Duddy’s The God-Men: An Inquiry into Witness Lee and the Local Church (IVP, 1981).

Biblical Foundations of Deification: John 17

Sometimes called “Johannine Mysticism,” deification is seen most clearly in the phrase “in Christ,” which occurs in the gospel and the letters. To my mind, the clearest statement is in John 17.

I ask not only on behalf of these, but also on behalf of those who will believe in me through their word, that they may all be one. As you, Father, are in me and I am in you, may they also be in us, so that the world may believe that you have sent me. The glory that you have given me I have given them, so that they may be one, as we are one, I in them and you in me, that they may become completely one, so that the world may know that you have sent me and have loved them even as you have loved me. (John 17)

I am going to remove a few clauses from this passage in order to focus on our union with God and with one another.

Our Unity is Based on the Unity of the Godhead

The reasons for complete unity are very important; ignoring the intended results of our complete unity undermines the alleged mission of the churches.  Jesus repeats almost verbatim one reason why our complete unity is essential: so that the world will believe and know that the Father sent Jesus (that the world may believe that you have sent me, and that the world may know that you have sent me). The second reason our complete unity is necessary is so that the world will know that Jesus has loved us even as the Father loved Jesus.

The main reasons for our unity is so that 1) the world will know that Jesus really was an Apostle of God, that he is totally reliable, and 2) the world will see love incarnate in God’s people. Since there are real-world results from this complete unity, the experience of this unity cannot be something exclusively reserved for the next life.

(Simple observation tells us that disunity in all its forms is a major barrier to the world finding reconciliation with God through Jesus Christ. All the hand-wringing and finger-pointing about our failure to “win the world for Christ” is worse than useless so long as we are unwilling to acknowledge this major, if not central, cause of that failure.)

Biblical Foundations of Deification: Pleroma (fullness, πληρωμα)

The second Biblical description of the deification of the Church is sprinkled through Ephesians and Colossians, and relates to the Pauline use of the word fullness, which in Greek is  πληρωμα, or pleroma. The word occurs several times in these letters, and we catch a glimpse (comparing scripture with scripture) of one of the mysteries of God that is, in the sense of inspiring awe, awesome.

First, pleroma is used to describe the deity of Christ.  The statement, generally agreed to be one of the strongest statements of the full deity of Christ in the Greek scriptures, is Colossians 1:19: In Christ all the fullness of the Deity lives in bodily form. This, as I said, is one of the strongest, single affirmations of the deity of Christ in the Bible.

Then we have pleroma is applied to the Church, twice in Ephesians as a future reality, and twice in Colossians as a present reality.

First we read, May you experience this love that surpasses knowledge—that you may be filled to the measure of all the fullness of God. (Ephesians 3:19) Next comes, until we all reach unity in the faith and in the knowledge of the Son of God and become mature, attaining to the whole measure of the fullness of Christ. (Ephesians 4:13)

Notice the two descriptions of that fullness: attaining to the whole measure of the fullness of Christ, and filled to the measure of all the fullness of God. The all-encompassing, complete reality of the fullness of God brimming over in us is unmistakeable. Also notice that there is nothing here to suggest that this occurs in some eschatological future. It seems to me that our experience of love, unity, and faith are located in the here and now.

Then there are two verses which affirm, not the future reality of the fullness of God in the church, but it’s present reality. The first of these follows the statement of the full deity of Christ we  looked at earlier. For in Christ all the fullness of the Deity lives in bodily form, and in Christ you have been brought to fullness. (Col 2:9-10)

The second present-tense statement regarding the fullness of God is by far the most astonishing declaration of Deification of any of these.

And God placed all things under his feet and appointed him to be head over everything for the church, which is his body, the fullness of him who fills everything in every way. (Ephesians 1:22-23)

Let me remove the phrases that obscure the extraordinary use of fullness here: The church is the fullness of God.

The Church is the Pleroma of God

So, in John 17 the Church is one with God by virtue of its union with Christ, and in Paul the Church is the fullness of God, the fullness of him who fills everything in every way. This is echoed in II Peter 1:4: he has granted to us his precious and very great promises, so that through them you may participate in the divine nature,  having escaped from the corruption that is in the world because of sinful desire. The word “participate” is κοινωνια, koinonia. Koinonia is variously rendered fellowship, sharers in, partakers of, etc., and is completely congruent with the Johannine and Pauline language describing deification, which is shorthand for “God became man so that man might become God.”

A Little of What has Gone Down for Me

Over the years I have been forcibly confronted by these Johannine and Pauline understandings about three times, and on those occasions my effect was the same. The enormity of the fact stopped me dead in my tracks for weeks, on one occasion for months. Of all the incomprehensible riches in Christ, this is the one that subsumes all others–untrackable, unmappable, inexhaustible. It says in Ephesians, To me, though I am the very least of all the saints, this grace was given,  to preach to the Gentiles the unsearchable riches of Christ.

I was stopped cold. My accomplishment and goals were, as Paul said of his own in his letter to the Philippians, simply σκυβαλαskubala, just so much shit.  My degrees, my shiny little victories, my goals and aspirations, were nothing.  My loss of enthusiasm was “spontaneous and unrehearsed.”

I was reminded of those motivational shutdowns recently when I saw something in Corinthians I hadn’t noticed before. The old way, with laws chiseled in stone, led to death, though it began with such glory that the people of Israel could not bear to look at Moses’ faceOn those previous occasions, when I caught a glimpse of the mystery of the new covenant, the glory was unbearable.

I haven’t had a beatific vision, but my experience could be compared to the via negativa or the “dark night of the soul,” from what I know of them. I am not a student of the mystics; in most things spiritual I have kept pretty close to the Bible. In that regard I think I may suffer from the Fundamentalist’s Curse. While other things factored in (like bipolar disorder), my subsequent path has been a repentance, or metanoia, from my fleshly intellectual inclinations.  Leaving seminary for the third and final time, giving up on a lifelong ambition for pastoral ministry, disposing of my 1,000-book library–these all resulted from a metanoia, changing my allegiance away from the church’s 2,000 year old κοσμος, and over to Christ.  As a young fundamentalist I learned that saying “But everybody else is doing it!” just doesn’t cut it.

It’s taken a while, but gradually I’ve pieced together something of what it means for me. First, Jesus the Messiah is my example, not some Perfect Absolute based on Greek philosophy, which is what the early church fathers saddled us with.  The kenosis passage in Philippians, with its understanding that Jesus emptied himself, is for me the main key.  Jesus emptied himself of his omniscience, omnipotence, and omnipresence, what are supposedly “essential attributes,” but remained God by virtue of the fact that God is love.

In two of my recent posts I discussed the unsearchable riches of Christ. Those contain for me most of what flows from deification. There are other truths and imperatives which result from our union with God in Christ, but those six are a good start.

Ascetic Practices and Protective Caveats

Two final things: for myself, I don’t believe in ascetic practices and abuse of the body as a means of attaining deification. From the point of view of scripture, deification is never an individual experience, it is always in the context of the entire church. The Pauline, present-tense expression of the fullness of God, together with the Johannine expectation of here-and-now effects on the κοσμος, indicate to me that in significant ways they are accomplished facts, just as God has seated us in heavenly places in Christ Jesus. For me, it is not so much an experience to be attained, but a reality to be experienced. The two are not, however, mutually exclusive.

Christian history has hedged this teaching about with a truckload of caveats, stipulations, conditions, and limitations intended to protect us from “going too far,” “getting ourselves into trouble,” and the like. A number of scriptural teachings should insure against dangers and abuse. These include avoiding the leaven of the scribes and Pharisees as well as the temptation to lord it over one another. On the positive side, a firm existential grounding in kenosis, the necessity of suffering, servanthood, and love should give us all protection we need.

______________________________________________

 To Read More in this Series, click on The Bride of Christ is God.

 

 

About these ads

About Ron Goetz

Lay leader, intellectual, struggler, disciple, writer, activist. Husband, father, grandpa, friend, son.
This entry was posted in Contemplative Prayer, Mysticism, Sanctification and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to “God Became Man that Man Might Become God”

  1. Patrick Mahoney says:

    I was driving to work this morning thinking about God and the day ahead, asking God to take my will and my life, guide me in my recovery, and show me how to live (its my usual morning prayer). My thoughts wondered to the passage that we are seated with Christ in heavenly places. Not in some future state, but now, even as I drove through traffic thinking about the tasks and events ahead.

    Coming home geting ready for dinner I read your blog. I thought it really meaningful and expressed what our journey is really all about. That complete perfect and joyful restoration of everything into harmony. Of cource I can’t fully understand this experience, but I trust that from God’s point of view, there may be no waiting for this to happen. And by the way, I always appreciated my Mormon friends and their ideas about theology. I am not saying I will someday be a creator god with my partner, but the idea of union with God seems to be discounted by many believers.

    Like

    • Ron Goetz says:

      Life is made up of little moments, some are discouraging, but many are encouraging.

      Someone observed that the when a person hears a new idea, they say no, they reject it. They need to hear it more than once before they come around. That goes for an activity proposal at church, or a Bible teaching. I’ve seen people reject new Bible teachings over and over. Same goes for union with God. Not heresy, but virtually unknown among rank-and-file Protestants.

      Like

  2. Hugh Magee says:

    Interestingly, in A COURSE IN MIRACLES, Jesus tells us we cannot “become God” because we are already forever a part of God. It is only our dream of separation that makes such a “becoming” seem real or necessary.

    Like

  3. Patrick Mahoney says:

    This is a topic full of so much meaning and opportunity for growth. It often seems that we think about spiritual realities as things that will happen in the future. Our view of reality is so narrow and limited. I am sure there are many good reasons for this, but as we are asked not to be “conformed” to this present world, it must be essential to expand our ideas and thinking, in order to be “transformed.”

    Becoming a Christian in an Evangelical community we heard about being transformed a lot, but it generally boiled down to not dancing, not swearing, attending lots of meetings, really avoiding any behaviors we thought “worldly.” The idea that this new life in Christ meant something other than just more time in heaven was rarely addressed. At least in regards to the quality of our relationships, the reality of what Christ has accomplished for us (being the lamb of God slain “before the foundations of the world”), and other radically different ways of seeing ourselves and the world around us.

    I gain so much encouragement and stimulation from these posts. Thank you Ron and Hugh for your take on the subject. In my current fellowship we say that honesty, open mindedness and willingness are essential for our “recovery” or spiritual growth. It is something I am grateful to be reminded of often, as I am prone to take my ideas and worldview as gospel. LOL

    Like

    • Ron Goetz says:

      There’s value in the civilizing and socializing missions of the church, which accounts for congregations that emphasize social rules. Those came in real handy on the American frontier and with the germanic barbarians, and with my kids. But some people are eventually inclined to go deeper, either introspectively, or evangelistically, or in activism. Learning to tolerate, and eventually embrace, this diversity is tough. I don’t feel nearly as impatient and irritated by other people’s “shallowness” as I used to.

      Wait. I take that back. I still get impatient and irritated. Oh, well.

      Like

      • Patrick Mahoney says:

        I had to laugh at that. Even for an old reprobate and heretic like me, I have to admit I like external rules and clear lines myself. Yes, you are so right about getting impatient and irritated. I still do this, but not as as much as I used to. I suppose that is either spiritual progress or maybe I just got tired of carrying around all that baggage. Wait, maybe that is spiritual growth! Anyway, I am getting ready to finish my workday and attend a Halloween Dance this evening with clean and sober friends. Not unlike what I did as an Evangelical almost 40 years ago, minus the dancing. LOL. Happy All Hallows Eve and All Saints Day to you.

        Like

  4. Colin George Garvie says:

    Thanks Ron. ‘Tis one of our most treasured doctrines. Charles Wesley expresses it beautifully in the hymn “Let Earth and Heaven Combine”.

    He deigns in flesh to appear,
    Widest extremes to join;
    To bring our vileness near,
    And make us all divine

    He also wrote:

    Eager for Thee I ask and pant;
    So strong, the principle divine
    Carries me out, with sweet constraint,
    Till all my hallowed soul is Thine;
    Plunged in the Godhead’s deepest sea,
    And lost in Thine immensity.

    Like

  5. Dr. Sebastian Painadadth SJ, India says:

    Theosis is the heart-beat of Christian spirituality. That we are human – we know. That we divine – this we realise through faith in Christ, the incarnate Word. The divine Logos became human, so that we humans can awaken the divinity dormant in us. This is a gift of grace which however demands asceticism and discipline, contemplation and compassion from our side.

    In a sense the experience of the divinisation of the human is the deepest meeting point of world religions. The divine Spirit brings about divinisation in the hearts of all human persons. Hence there is a sense of the Divine in every spiritual seeker. This is escpecially found in the mystical traditions of all religions, very conspicuously in Vedanta Hinduism, Sufi Islam and Jewish Kabbala.

    Dr. Sebastian Painadath SJ, India . posted 30.08.2014

    Like

So what are you thinking?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s